News & insights

Comparing print and digital media: Insights on sustainability, reading, marketing and the digital divide

4 July 2024

View the Intergraf Report here!

In today’s fast-paced digital era, the debate between print and digital media continues to evolve. While digital platforms offer convenience and interactivity, print media holds unique advantages in terms of sustainability, reading comprehension, marketing efficacy, and bridging the digital divide. This blog post delves into these aspects, drawing insights from a comprehensive report comparing print and digital communication tools.

Sustainability

The environmental impact of both print and digital media is a critical concern in the sustainability debate. Contrary to popular belief, the digital sector has a significant environmental footprint. The Information and Communication Technology (ICT) sector is responsible for 2-4% of global emissions and is increasingly energy-intensive. This growth in energy consumption often outweighs the potential energy-saving benefits of digitalisation​​.

Print media, often perceived as less eco-friendly, has made strides in sustainability practices. Modern printing techniques and responsible sourcing of materials have reduced the environmental impact of print products. Also, the recycling rate of paper is generally higher compared to electronic waste, which poses a substantial challenge in terms of proper disposal and recycling.

Reading Comprehension and Leisure

When it comes to reading comprehension, print media still holds a fundamental role. Academic literature suggests that print facilitates better reading comprehension, particularly for complex texts and educational materials. Digital reading, while expanding the definition of reading through e-books and audiobooks, does not entirely replace the functions of print books. Instead, digital formats complement print by offering benefits like accessibility, portability, and customisation​.

Experienced readers often switch between print and digital formats based on context and preference. For example, digital books are preferred for light, on-the-go reading, while print books are favoured for more intensive reading sessions that require deeper engagement and retention​. Studies also indicate that students who balance both formats tend to read more for enjoyment compared to those who stick to only one format​​.

Marketing Efficacy

In the realm of marketing, both print and digital media have their unique strengths. Digital marketing excels in interactivity and targeted engagement, but print media still plays a crucial role in cutting through the digital noise. Print marketing materials, such as brochures, catalogues, and direct mail, create lasting impressions and evoke stronger emotional responses compared to digital ads​.

Print and digital marketing can synergise effectively. For instance, integrating QR codes in print materials can enhance digital engagement, and direct mail can complement email marketing efforts to increase customer retention. This balanced approach maximizes the reach and impact of marketing campaigns, leveraging the strengths of both media​.

Bridging the Digital Divide

Despite the rapid digitalisation, a significant digital divide persists, particularly in the European Union. Access to digital technologies and skills varies widely, with vulnerable groups (such as rural residents, the elderly, and those with lower education levels) often being left behind. Print media serves as a crucial communication tool for these groups, ensuring that important information reaches everyone, regardless of their digital proficiency​​.

Statistics highlight the disparities in digital skills across different regions and demographics. For example, while more than 50% of individuals in Northern Europe possess above-basic digital skills, less than 20% in South-eastern Europe do. This divide underscores the importance of maintaining print communication to ensure inclusivity and equitable access to information​.

Conclusion

The comparison between print and digital media reveals that both have distinct advantages and should be viewed as complementary rather than substitutive. Print media offers sustainability benefits, supports deeper reading comprehension, enhances marketing efforts through its unique impact, and helps bridge the digital divide. Meanwhile, digital media provides interactivity, accessibility, and convenience. Adopting a balanced approach that leverages the strengths of both media is essential for effective communication in today’s multifaceted landscape.

As technology and media continue to evolve, ongoing research and a critical evaluation of methodologies will be vital in understanding and optimising the roles of print and digital media. If you’re curious in finding out how you could be utilising both print and digital media, contact us and get in touch!

Share on social

Related articles

The giving generation: How charities can connect with Gen Z

The giving generation: How charities can connect with Gen Z

For most charities, a key part of their ongoing income generation strategy will be the recruitment of new donors. And as part of that, the recruitment of younger donors is also high on most charities’ agendas in order to counteract the natural attrition inherent in an...

To discount, or not to discount: Time to jack in Black Friday?

To discount, or not to discount: Time to jack in Black Friday?

It started as Black Friday, extended to Cyber Monday, grew to Cyber Weekend and now has its own Cyber Week – has the annual sales campaign lost its meaning?  Apparently not.  Seasonal sales are on their way Soaring sales Soaring sales  59% of Brits are...

Data-driven marketing for charities in the era of budget cuts

Data-driven marketing for charities in the era of budget cuts

Join the Dots and Herdify webinar – register now In today's challenging landscape, where charity budgets are shrinking and traditional marketing methods are becoming increasingly costly, standing out is more critical than ever. With all charities vying for the same...

State of the charity sector January-June 2024, our thoughts 

State of the charity sector January-June 2024, our thoughts 

You may have seen Wood for Trees, part of Salocin Group, recently released its six-monthly update on the state of the charity sector report (January-June 2024). We’ve had a good look through it, digested it and here are our thoughts…   Lori Cridland – Media...

The Drum Live – roundup of key outtakes

The Drum Live – roundup of key outtakes

Our Senior Media Account Director, Jodie Hanrahan, was invited to speak at The Drum Live (25 September 2024) alongside fellow Creative Futures team members Cathy Bittner from Canon Europe and Rob Flannery from Nutshell Creative. They spoke about the campaign they...

3 classic behavioural science techniques for marketers

3 classic behavioural science techniques for marketers

And 3 very cool nudges What is behavioural science?  Behavioural science is the study of how cultural, psychological and societal factors drive human behaviour. Within marketing, it’s used to influence attitudes and buying behaviour. The application of this...

State of the charity sector – our views 

State of the charity sector – our views 

You may have seen Wood for Trees, part of Salocin Group, recently released its annual state of the charity sector report. We’ve had a good look through it, digested it and here are our thoughts…  Clare Arndell – Head of Media Planning & Operations ...

Join the Dots awarded IPA People First Promise

Join the Dots awarded IPA People First Promise

We’re delighted to share we’ve been awarded the Institute of Practitioners in Advertising (IPA)’s People First Promise, just as Mental Health Awareness Week 2024 kicks off. This badge of honour represents everything the Salocin Group and its agency brands – Join the...

7 things that top global digital media companies have in common

7 things that top global digital media companies have in common

The number of people who go online every day is constantly increasing. In fact, it’s probably gone up since you finished reading that sentence.

Digital media is an integral part of our daily lives. Most people use some form of digital media every day, right from the moment they wake up – and with so many people consuming digital media, it’s no wonder digital media is one of the most powerful ways to build a connection with your audience.

Adapt Your Donor Acquisition Strategy

Adapt Your Donor Acquisition Strategy

As we find ourselves battling another year of disease, war and likely recession, the need for strategy and methodical planning is more crucial than ever. No one should be suffering losses during these uncertain times.